A field study of Black Bostonian speech scheduled to start just as the COVID-19 pandemic hit might have been shelved for years.
Instead, a groundbreaking online alternative has generated more鈥攁nd richer鈥攊nterviews than would have been possible with a more traditional approach, the researchers say.
In early 2019, Monica Nesbitt, then a Society of Fellows postdoctoral researcher, was planning to take students in her 鈥淟anguage and Ethnicity鈥 class to greater Boston to interview members of the city鈥檚 Black community.
When the trip was canceled, the class turned to social media, creating promoting the study鈥攖he 鈥攚hich builds on Linguistics Department chair James Stanford鈥檚 longtime work with students documenting life and language in New England.
Sprinkles or Jimmies?
Psychology and linguistics major Akiah Watts 鈥22 developed a social media game strategy to engage prospective participants. Visitors to the page are invited to take short word-choice quizzes Watts and her classmates created, such as sprinkles or jimmies? Supper or dinner? In the interviews, participants weigh in on additional New England regionalisms, including 鈥渨icked smart.鈥
She also posted photos and descriptions of the researchers to 鈥渉umanize the page,鈥 which increases the account鈥檚 credibility, says Watts, who was recently awarded a grant from the Kaminsky Family Fund in support of her senior honors thesis in linguistics.
So far, those efforts have resulted in 96 interviews on Zoom, most conducted by Watts, that range from 45 to 90 minutes in length.
Had they relied on traditional field study methods鈥攃hatting with people on the sidewalk or at bus stops鈥攃ompleting that many interviews would have taken years and years, says Nesbitt, now an assistant professor of linguistics at Indiana University.
Research assistant Guadalupe Ortega 鈥23 notes that the longer format allows for a more complete understanding of each speaker, and the language they use.
In addition to asking participants to pronounce certain words, the interviewers gather extensive background information, as well as additional data, such as their perspectives on the Boston accent, says Ortega, a linguistics and women鈥檚 gender and sexuality studies major who manages the transcribers and coders and helps process the recordings. 鈥淚t鈥檚 very interesting get to see the full picture of each person.鈥
Place, Race, and Class
The study鈥檚 goals include expanding the limited existing linguistic data on Black speakers in eastern Massachusetts, 鈥済iving voice to people who have been left out in the past,鈥 says Watts.
The project also investigates whether Black speakers have Boston features, addressing a question that often seems to crop up in the literature, says Nesbitt, who specializes in phonology and sociolinguistics.
Within sociolinguistic studies in urban centers with regional features, such as New York or Chicago, a common narrative is that Black speakers do not participate in those accents, she says. 鈥淪ometimes it鈥檚 true, and sometimes it鈥檚 not.鈥
鈥淪aying there are regional differences between speakers in the white community, but not within this other set of speakers, and perhaps that has something to do with their racial identity鈥攚hen that just can鈥檛 be true鈥攈elps to other Black speakers,鈥 Nesbitt says. 鈥淲e know place and where people are from is as much as part of their identity as their race or social class.鈥
鈥榃e Feel Privileged鈥
The project also looks at the pandemic鈥檚 effect on the communities being studied. Though it wasn鈥檛 planned, many participants found the conversations therapeutic, the researchers say.
Participants often talk about racial justice issues鈥攊ncluding health care disparities related to COVID-19鈥攁nd how the pandemic is affecting their families and coworkers, says Nesbitt, who will continue the research with her students at Indiana University. 鈥淲e feel privileged to be documenting this.鈥
To align with the study鈥檚 goals, the interviews have been conducted by students who identify as Black.
鈥淥ne thing that we know about sociolinguistic research is people will change the way that they speak depending on whether or not the person interviewing them has similar characteristics,鈥 says Nesbitt.
Watts, Ortega, and their cohort, including prior fieldworkers George Stain and Soren Tyler, also 鈥23s, have provided 鈥減henomenal support for this much-needed project,鈥 Nesbitt says. 鈥淭hese students have been outstanding in their commitment to quantitative research, as well as pushing social justice initiatives in our work.鈥
The study is already being discussed on the national stage. Last year, Nesbitt, Stain, Stanford, and Watts gave a workshop, 鈥淪ociolinguistic Research in the Time of COVID: Methods, Ethics, Theory,鈥 at the Linguistic Society of America鈥檚 annual meeting. And a related paper co-authored by Nesbitt and Watts will be published in an upcoming issue of Linguistics Vanguard.
The project received seed funding from the Society of Fellows and is now being funded by the linguistics departments at 天美麻豆 and Indiana University.